Nature Strollers Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Eating our for Thanksgiving

who's talking here?

Kat 2
suzyq 4
beccafan 1
adina 4
tracey 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

suzyq --- 18 years ago -

I think I need a break this year from cooking Thanksgiving Dinner and was wondering if anyone knows of a great restaurant to go to for Thanksgiving day? Any suggestions would greatly be appreciated.  

adina --- 18 years ago -

We decided that same thing last year. We called around and found that many places charged an arm and a leg, which I did not mind too much for the adults, but for my then 1 1/2 and 4 1/2 year old kids, they also charged what I thought was an exorbitant amount (some places the same charge as for adults, others just a little bit less), and yes they were going to charge for the 1 1/2 year old! Ultimately we decided to try out the Hotel Thayer in West Point. The cost was not too bad, though still a good amount of money (I forge tnow how much exactly). It was a complete dissapointment, both the service and the food were absolutely horrendous. The only thing we liked was the view out the window and the walk we took outside after the "meal". On our walk we happened to pass by the dumpster which was filled with #10 cans from the kitchen, nearly everything from the meal came out of one of those, candied yams, other vegetables, etc. UUUggghhhhhh--- thinking about it now makes me cringe. The local diner (which I am not a particular fan of) would have been a much better choice. So, cross that place off your list, if you were possibly considering it. Unfortunately other than that, I don't have any other reccomendations. Not sure what we will end up doing this year. Good luck and I am curious to hear about your experience! --Adina 

suzyq --- 18 years ago -

So good to hear your review as on other loops I have nothing but good about the Thayer Hotel. So far, that is the only name that came up. Maybe it is a little early to consider Thanksgiving, as so far none of the local restaurants have advertised anything. Will let you know what we end up doing. 

adina --- 18 years ago -

 

adina --- 18 years ago -

We had heard all good about the Thayer too (especially the Sunday Brunch), which is why we figured 'how can we go wrong?' Were we ever suprised! Words really do not fully express what a horrible meal and experience it was. We were astonished that they are able to get away with that and still maintain their reputation. We wondered if just the Thanksgiving dinner there is awful or if the brunch is like that too.... 

tracey --- 18 years ago -

 

tracey --- 18 years ago -

just throw the bird in (thats the easy part) and potluck the rest! i worked last year, and chris handled the bird and family came up after w/side dishes... i am working this year too 

Kat --- 18 years ago -

This is going to sound crazy but one year my mother-in-law had shoulder surgery, and she couldn't prepare the meal for Thanksgiving. The girls were only about a year old and so there was no way I could do it either. She placed a pickup order from Boston Market... and MAN it was so good! Now eveyone knows that I am a human garbage disposal and will eat anything and everything you put in front of me (expect things I am allergic to or is part of one of my irrational food prejudices), so I am not the best judge... but my fellow guests enjoyed the meal very much. It was nice because we didn't want to go out with the girls, so this was a great compromise... an inexpensive yet delicious meal you could eat in your own home. 

beccafan --- 18 years ago -

ok--here is my suggestion. Adina is right. Dealing with a restaurant can be really sticky and there is no guarantee your family, kids and all will deal wonderfully with the crowds and even like the food. Here is what I suggest--hannoford offers the entire thanksgiging meal already cooked and ready to heat. It comes in a catering type package including, turkey or ham, potatoes, dinner rolls, cranberry, even a pie for dessert. You have to go to the deli counter to place the order WELL IN ADVANCE>. start asking at the end of oct when the ordering begins---they only preorder a certin amount of dinners and when they sell out they are done.---They you still get to relax the whole day at home without crowds and strangers. 

Kat --- 18 years ago -

Sam, I agree... I think eating at home via a catered or take-out thing is SO much easier. It's also so much more enjoyable to be in the comfort of your own home! 

suzyq --- 18 years ago -

Great suggestions. Pot luck won't really work for my family. I have some family traveling far and some well, that don't cook at all. I love hosting holidays but feel so worn out this year. I like the catering at home. We don't have a Hannaford around here but maybe some of the other markets do the same. I will look into it. Thanks again. 

adina --- 18 years ago -

Great ideas! I'll bet you could order from Adams Fairacre Farms, they are wonderful! FYI: we will be having a Thanksgiving Open House and Market at our farm the day before Thanksgiving, I will post the info in the next few weeks. But we won't have much (if any) prepared food, mostly raw ingredients (AKA veggies!). 

suzyq --- 18 years ago -

We decided on going to the Grand Cascade Lodge in Hardyston / Vernon NJ. This is the first time they are hosting a Thanksgiving Dinner so I am not sure how it will be but we are going to give it a try. Thanks again for all of the suggestions. I will let you know if it was worth going there. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Nature Strollers Underground